Hm, have never given mine coley, but I've got to try it. They both LOVE steamed salmon fillet, and Monkey likes chicken. For a real treat, nothing beats prawns, though - my OH once bought some
enormous tiger prawns over the counter, seriously the biggest ones I've ever seen, and the cats nearly passed out with excitement. They were very happy cats that night. Parma ham also goes down very well, although I only ever give them very small pieces because of the salt content. Has to be a good (expensive...) variety, though.
My babies also have some weird fancies - Monkey is seriously CRAZY about rocket
, and Poppy loves carrots (cooked or raw) and baby spinach leaves. In fact, if there's no spinach or rocket around, they will make do with stealing any other salad leaf... And Monkey always tries to lick my lips when I'm eating toffees. Oh, and they both steal my herbal teas (I usually drink it lukewarm or cold - I never put hot liquids where they could get to them!). Peppermint and chamomile seem to be their favourites.
I do sometimes feel bad when my OH comes home and smells something nice cooking, only to be told that it's for Poppy and Monkey.