Jakey is a pain, I love him but he is a pain. No matter what the brand will only eat the Jelly, when he's bored he eats the jelly (just the jelly, all the meat is left going dry and unappetising) usually eats Felix or Tesco's own Supreme one which he loves. When they stopped producing it a while back I tried him on Hi-life, he turned his nose up, Sheba same result in fact the better the quality the more he turned his nose up and looked at me accusing me of starving him. He is a fairly big cat and no matter how many times you walk past his food bowl he will follow and sit and wait looking pathetic, desparately trying to convince me that he is a poor starving wretch. Have now taken to feed the pouches a little at a time, otherwise he would be on 5 or six a day. He has eaten Hills Science but wasted more than he ate. He is the equivalent of a meat and two veg as opposed to gourmet cooking. Oh and thank heavens Tesco started the jelly ones again, he thinks he is in cat heaven.