I've been trying to find the reference to the American vet association recommendations for you but I keep coming up against members only sites. I'll keep trying though because I know from experience what vets can be like when you question their treatment, however politely you put it. They will tell you that anything below 5 mg bd is a sub-therapeutic dose which may well be the case (although some people on a board I was on had cats well-controlled on less). However, the point is that slow upward titration to a therapeutic dose is better for the cat.
I have found a couple of references though. One is in the book 'Consultations in feline internal medicine' by John R August, published by Elsevier Health Sciences. It says
'the starting dose is now **2.5mg twice daily** then recheck in 3 weeks. If any adverse symptoms are noted, then recheck sooner. It only takes **1 week** for Tapazole to stabilize in the bloodstream. Past recommendations were as high as 5mg 3 times a day for 3 weeks. The other is mentioned on Tanya's feline crf site under related diseases (
www.felinecrf.org).
Your Fluffers sounds even smaller than my Tiny (2.8 kg) and he had terrible side effects including constant vomiting when he was started on 5 mg bd. At one stage he was so poorly I thought I was going to lose him (and I think the vet did too) so I stopped all medication (with grudging vet approval). He got better (well, still hyper-T of course) and we then started treatment again on a lower dose. It was always a bit of a balancing act between controlling the thyroid and making him vomit but we got there in the end.
If you and your vet do decide to go down the lower dosage route you may need to change Fluffers to carbimazole (which is what used to be used until recently) rather than Felimazole because the tablets are not coated and can therefore be split.
By the way, during my searching I found arthralgia listed as a common side effect of felimazole so that may be Fluffers problem and it may resolve when she gets used to her new euthyroid state.