Definitely, so she has had her supper biscuits stopped to accomodate pinching his, and I shall be on my guard from tonight - I did trick her last night, I emptied his biscuit bowl back into the tin and then left it - she went running up to it, so I am right, she is hte one eating it, not him. The other downside to that is he is a very slim cat, and I would actually like to see a small amount of weight on him, but not much chance if Lucy is eating it!!